QUESTIONS AND RESPONSES

Question: Our district is piloting AI classroom observation tools that track teacher talk time, student engagement, and instructional patterns. Teachers are nervous. How should the board approach this?      -- Board Member in Massachusetts

  • TESBM: It is reasonable that any changes and uses of technology like this have the potential to be unnerving. Unless the board has adopted a Guardrail that explicitly speaks to appropriate technology usage or teacher evaluation, then teacher nervousness about technological intelligence being used for evaluation is owned by management, not the board. By default, the superintendent owns the relationship with teachers, the implementation of the evaluation system, and the communication about how the data will be used. The board's first priority isn’t to soothe teacher anxiety. The board’s job in situations like these is to choose whether or not the community value on this topic is so high priority that it needs to set boundaries within which the superintendent can use the tool. If it’s not a community high priority, the board leaves the delegation to the superintendent in place. If it is a community high priority, the board needs to establish the boundaries.

  • What are those boundaries? If the board is going to adopt a Guardrail related to this, it needs to be very clear about the value being protected. Is it about what data can’t be used for? Is the Guardrail that these tools can’t be the sole basis for a negative evaluation? Is it that the data can’t be shared publicly in a way that identifies individual teachers? Can it not be used to rank teachers against each other? The more clarity, the greater the likelihood that the community values are protected. Once the Guardrail is in place, the superintendent has clear direction and the teachers have clear protections.

  • If the board chooses to use one of its five Guardrails on this community value, then do so. But if not, this is the superintendent’s job.

Question: Students in our schools are using AI to write essays and complete assignments. We need an academic integrity policy that addresses AI. Where do we start?      -- Board Member in Maine

  • TESBM: Before you write a Guardrail about protecting learning, define what learning looks like. The instinct is to start with the prohibition on the use of technological intelligence: “No AI on essays. No AI on homework. No AI on take-home tests.” But a ban focused policy works from the assumption that the board knows exactly where the line between acceptable and unacceptable use is. With established tools and technologies, that may well be the case. But when it comes to technological intelligence and its emerging impact on all facets of our lives, it’s less clear when using it is cheating and when it’s a legitimate tool. That line simply isn’t as obvious as most boards think. What about using this technology to brainstorm ideas? Using it to check grammar? Using it to translate for an English learner?

  • The better starting point in these unique circumstances is a conversation about what the board wants students to know and be able to do when they graduate. If the board wants students who can write independently, the conversation should first define what independent writing means and empower the superintendent to design assessments that evaluate for it. If the board wants students who can use these new technologies productively, the conversation should define what productive use means and what it means for teachers to teach it. If those conversations lead to a clear prohibition, a Guardrail may be in order. But if not, it may be best to hold off and learn more first. Once the community value is completely clear, the rest of the Guardrail writes itself.

Question: We had a split vote on adopting new vision statements and now some members are accusing the majority of not being transparent. How should the board handle disagreements about process without it becoming personal?      -- Board Member in Washington

  • TESBM: Split votes on a foundational document often create the same dynamic: the majority feels attacked and the minority feels ignored. Staff and the community see division and people begin to question the process. This pattern starts long before the vote. When language starts getting drafted without first getting clarity about what is being done, why, and how the process will go, it’s hard to recover after the fact.

  • It starts when the board doesn’t agree on what a vision statement is for. If half the board sees it as a marketing exercise and the other half sees it as a governing document, the process will feel broken no matter how transparent it is. The disagreement isn’t about transparency, it’s about purpose. Reach clarity (and preferably consensus) about the purpose first. The board needs to agree on what a vision statement does before it agrees on what it says. Does it guide the superintendent's priorities? Does it communicate to the community? Does it anchor the board's own decision-making?

  • Once the board agrees on the purpose, the criteria for an effective vision statement become clear, and the process for creating one becomes more transparent by definition. Start the next meeting with a purpose conversation, not a language conversation. The accusation of insufficient transparency is often a signal that the board skipped the purpose step.


UPCOMING WEBINAR

Effective AI Policy

  • Join us next month for a conversation about nurting biological intelligence in the age of technological intelligence. This topic has been requested for quite a while now so we look forward to the conversation.

  • 11am central on Friday, November 13, 2026

Did you miss last month's 30-minute free webinar? Email Greg for a make-up session on any of our growing list of topics, including governance policy, delegation policy, effective budgeting, superintendent evaluation, professional services management, strategic planning, consent agendas, and more.


BONUS MATERIALS

For paid subscribers, here are links to additional resources (to gain access to the links below, please consider subscribing):

  • Effective Goal & Guardrail Setting

  • Effective Policy Leadership


Question we can answer? Submit it to our coaches

Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe to the newsletter.

Enjoying? Forward this to regional / state / national colleagues